The Gold Road Chapter – which includes the Scribing system – and Update 42 is now available to test on the PTS! You can read the latest patch notes here: https://forums.elderscrollsonline.com/en/discussion/656454/
Maintenance for the week of April 29:
• PC/Mac: No maintenance – April 29
We will be performing maintenance for patch 10.0.2 on the PTS on Monday at 8:00AM EDT (12:00 UTC).
Leave a Reply
ESO_Nightingale
✭✭✭✭✭
✭✭✭✭
Hey everyone, i know i posted late this week, i've been really busy with work and mythic raiding in world of warcraft (i managed to get cutting edge!) and i've been kind of disuaded from testing due to the amount of crashes i've been through on the pts, but today i just wanted to go over some concerning things with the new scribing system.
Namely, these being the frost damage skills and their uh... major shortcomings.
Ulfsild's (Chilling) Contingency:
To start off, this was the 1 ability i thought would be somewhat viable, though after testing, i realised that it just simply does not do enough dps output in single target to ever warrant taking over other existing damage over time skills such as barbed trap or degeneration. it ended up being a weak "delayed" aoe burst damage effect with a minor damage over time effect on it with a really short duration. i'm not sure why or when this would be useful, but i suppose it exists. i really wish the lingering torment damage over time effect was a lot stronger, having more duration and damage so that it might be used as a frost damage over time skill.
EDIT: because the 20% duration increase spell is currently broken, this spell is not getting as much value out of lingering torment as it should be. outside of this, its solid enough when used as a pseudo spammable.
Elemental (Chilling) Explosion:
this one is really incredibly disapointing. i'm not sure who thought that a 2 second ground placed aoe damage over time with a travel time was a good idea in an action combat game, but the reward for using this skill for damage simply is not there. on top of the damage over time portion from lingering torment also being a measily 5 seconds, the delay in order for the damage to actually work is frankly insane. i have a 13-16k tooltip on this ability. in the 3 gcds it takes for this ability to go off, i could have casted 3 frost pulsars or frost reaches for more damage overall without the insane cast time restrictions. this is an ability design that should absolutely see some massive iteration. this is simply not worth casting ever. i wouldn't mind using this skill if it did SIGNIFICANTLY more damage, or if it was a lot more friendly to play with, such as being a placed ability that takes multiple seconds to go off, similar to something like shadow silk.
Assassins misery definitely is a stronger effect than Lingering torment, however, it turns it from being a damage over time skill into a filler spammable type skill, in which case i'd much rather just spam frost reach for the weapon and spell damage bonus in addition to not having to sit there hardcasting.
I really hope that there are more plans in the future to introduce the frost script to more of the scribing skills as its very disappointing to recieve 2 of these lackluster abilities as the only 2 new scribing skills that even work with frost damage.
Edited by ESO_Nightingale on April 22, 2024 4:04AM
PvE Frost Warden Main and teacher for ESO-U. Frost Warden PvE Build Article: https://eso-u.com/articles/nightingales_warden_dps_guide__frost_knight. Come Join the ESO Frost Discord to discuss everything frost!: https://discord.gg/5PT3rQX
#1
7
Lystrad
✭✭
Given that the soul magic skills have the shock damage script I was kind of surprised that they only have the shock damage script. I had kind of figured they would have had all 3 destruction damage types to make sure everyone had access to a class/weapon agnostic spammable of their preferred destruction element.
#2
7
Seraphayel
✭✭✭✭✭
✭✭✭✭✭Lystrad wrote: »
Given that the soul magic skills have the shock damage script I was kind of surprised that they only have the shock damage script. I had kind of figured they would have had all 3 destruction damage types to make sure everyone had access to a class/weapon agnostic spammable of their preferred destruction element.
This is clearly an oversight and should be done asap in my opinion. I really dont know why they’re limiting damage type at all. Every damage skill should have every damage script available.
PS5
EU
Aldmeri Dominion
- Khajiit Arcanist -
#3
6
ESO_Nightingale
✭✭✭✭✭
✭✭✭✭Seraphayel wrote: »
Lystrad wrote: »
Given that the soul magic skills have the shock damage script I was kind of surprised that they only have the shock damage script. I had kind of figured they would have had all 3 destruction damage types to make sure everyone had access to a class/weapon agnostic spammable of their preferred destruction element.
This is clearly an oversight and should be done asap in my opinion. I really dont know why they’re limiting damage type at all. Every damage skill should have every damage script available.
I agree. Though i understand that it takes time to develop visual effects for this type of thing, they should retroactively add every damage type to every damage grimoire.
PvE Frost Warden Main and teacher for ESO-U. Frost Warden PvE Build Article: https://eso-u.com/articles/nightingales_warden_dps_guide__frost_knight. Come Join the ESO Frost Discord to discuss everything frost!: https://discord.gg/5PT3rQX
#4
1
LeHarrt91
✭✭✭✭✭
✭I agree that more of the skills should have gotten more of the Elemental Types. its a shame to see so few.
PS NA 1800+ CP
Have played all classes.
Warden Main#5
3
NyassaV
✭✭✭✭✭
✭✭Ulfsild's Contingency is going to be very good for PvP. It's basically budget Shalks.
Flawless Conqueror ~ Grand Overlord
She/Her ~ PC/NA | I record things for fun and for info
#6
w002exp
✭✭✭
Lystrad wrote: »
Given that the soul magic skills have the shock damage script I was kind of surprised that they only have the shock damage script. I had kind of figured they would have had all 3 destruction damage types to make sure everyone had access to a class/weapon agnostic spammable of their preferred destruction element.
In fact lore wise youd think fire would definitely be there since Skyrim has a no kidding fiery soul trap spell.
#7
Finedaible
✭✭✭✭✭
✭✭I had hoped that Scribing would have allowed a larger variety of damage types for more diversified or specialized gameplay. Makes me wonder why they even bothered making damage-specific sets like War Maiden, Netch's Touch, Automaton, Ysgramor's Birthright, etc. if type sourcing is going to remain as arbitrary as it is.
If there were damage resistance and/or status resistance nodes in the champion point system, more diversity from the Scribing system would have enabled a more dynamic, chess-like system of damage checks the game had originally intended for without penalizing players in PvE.
#8
3
Unified_Gaming
✭✭✭✭
NyassaV wrote: »
Ulfsild's Contingency is going to be very good for PvP. It's basically budget Shalks.
It is awkward to use as it doesn't delay well. You cast it then the next resource cost procs it i.e. roll dodge. This means you can't use it on nb say you cast the contingency then cloak - skill proc'd so can't open with it. Cast it then spamable you get a little extra but not enough to make it a burst skill so again feels wasted and better just doing 2 spamables for more net damage as it is an aoe skill so hits less than single target.
Unified Gaming - creating a shared and Unified Gaming community.
For some of the best and most up to date PVP builds around or useful tips and tricks from an experienced player for PvP and PvE, then check out my channel and consider subscribing if you want to see regular ESO content.
#9
Unified_Gaming
✭✭✭✭
ESO_Nightingale wrote: »
Hey everyone, i know i posted late this week, i've been really busy with work and mythic raiding in world of warcraft (i managed to get cutting edge!) and i've been kind of disuaded from testing due to the amount of crashes i've been through on the pts, but today i just wanted to go over some concerning things with the new scribing system.
Namely, these being the frost damage skills and their uh... major shortcomings.
Ulfsild's (Chilling) Contingency:
To start off, this was the 1 ability i thought would be somewhat viable, though after testing, i realised that it just simply does not do enough dps output in single target to ever warrant taking over other existing damage over time skills such as barbed trap or degeneration. it ended up being a weak "delayed" aoe burst damage effect with a minor damage over time effect on it with a really short duration. i'm not sure why or when this would be useful, but i suppose it exists. i really wish the lingering torment damage over time effect was a lot stronger, having more duration and damage so that it might be used as a frost damage over time skill.EDIT: because the 20% duration increase spell is currently broken, this spell is not getting as much value out of lingering torment as it should be. outside of this, its solid enough when used as a pseudo spammable.
Elemental (Chilling) Explosion:
this one is really incredibly disapointing. i'm not sure who thought that a 2 second ground placed aoe damage over time with a travel time was a good idea in an action combat game, but the reward for using this skill for damage simply is not there. on top of the damage over time portion from lingering torment also being a measily 5 seconds, the delay in order for the damage to actually work is frankly insane. i have a 13-16k tooltip on this ability. in the 3 gcds it takes for this ability to go off, i could have casted 3 frost pulsars or frost reaches for more damage overall without the insane cast time restrictions. this is an ability design that should absolutely see some massive iteration. this is simply not worth casting ever. i wouldn't mind using this skill if it did SIGNIFICANTLY more damage, or if it was a lot more friendly to play with, such as being a placed ability that takes multiple seconds to go off, similar to something like shadow silk.
Assassins misery definitely is a stronger effect than Lingering torment, however, it turns it from being a damage over time skill into a filler spammable type skill, in which case i'd much rather just spam frost reach for the weapon and spell damage bonus in addition to not having to sit there hardcasting.I really hope that there are more plans in the future to introduce the frost script to more of the scribing skills as its very disappointing to recieve 2 of these lackluster abilities as the only 2 new scribing skills that even work with frost damage.
I wish the damage options on the primary scripts was this - basically a 'damage' tab that when you select it you can then pick any damage type. This change alone would make you have MANY more frost skills i.e. smash, torch bearer etc.
Primary script
>Damage (which loads separate menu - see below):
..........Frost
..........Poison
..........Fire
..........Defile
..........ETC.
>Healing
>Shield
etc.The contingency name doesn't feel right in its current design. I wish it had more control over the proc in the secondary scripts which let you focus on your playstyle/needs - in this case a magden:
- Script of delaying strike [amplify the effect by 40% but cause the effect to trigger after 3 seconds e.g. 10k spamable becomes 14k burst skill] creating a frost burst skill.
- Script of affliction [Amplify the the damage by 100% but spread the damager over 20s i.e. 10k spamable becomes 20k dot]
- Script of contingency [when below 50% of your primary stat cause the trigger]
- Script of Emergency [when below 30% hp cause the effect] i.e. auto heal
- Script of freedom [when afflicted with a snare or immobilize trigger the effect] e.g. auto snare removal or heal or armour buff as big hit coming
- Script of protection [The next time you take damage, the effect is triggered] e.g. make it give armour buff
- Script of foresight [The next time you damage a target, trigger the effect] i.e. cast skill to give crit buffs or damage buffThoughts?
Edited by Unified_Gaming on April 22, 2024 8:11PM
Unified Gaming - creating a shared and Unified Gaming community.
For some of the best and most up to date PVP builds around or useful tips and tricks from an experienced player for PvP and PvE, then check out my channel and consider subscribing if you want to see regular ESO content.
#10
2
ESO_Nightingale
✭✭✭✭✭
✭✭✭✭Unified_Gaming wrote: »
ESO_Nightingale wrote: »
Hey everyone, i know i posted late this week, i've been really busy with work and mythic raiding in world of warcraft (i managed to get cutting edge!) and i've been kind of disuaded from testing due to the amount of crashes i've been through on the pts, but today i just wanted to go over some concerning things with the new scribing system.
Namely, these being the frost damage skills and their uh... major shortcomings.
Ulfsild's (Chilling) Contingency:
To start off, this was the 1 ability i thought would be somewhat viable, though after testing, i realised that it just simply does not do enough dps output in single target to ever warrant taking over other existing damage over time skills such as barbed trap or degeneration. it ended up being a weak "delayed" aoe burst damage effect with a minor damage over time effect on it with a really short duration. i'm not sure why or when this would be useful, but i suppose it exists. i really wish the lingering torment damage over time effect was a lot stronger, having more duration and damage so that it might be used as a frost damage over time skill.EDIT: because the 20% duration increase spell is currently broken, this spell is not getting as much value out of lingering torment as it should be. outside of this, its solid enough when used as a pseudo spammable.
Elemental (Chilling) Explosion:
this one is really incredibly disapointing. i'm not sure who thought that a 2 second ground placed aoe damage over time with a travel time was a good idea in an action combat game, but the reward for using this skill for damage simply is not there. on top of the damage over time portion from lingering torment also being a measily 5 seconds, the delay in order for the damage to actually work is frankly insane. i have a 13-16k tooltip on this ability. in the 3 gcds it takes for this ability to go off, i could have casted 3 frost pulsars or frost reaches for more damage overall without the insane cast time restrictions. this is an ability design that should absolutely see some massive iteration. this is simply not worth casting ever. i wouldn't mind using this skill if it did SIGNIFICANTLY more damage, or if it was a lot more friendly to play with, such as being a placed ability that takes multiple seconds to go off, similar to something like shadow silk.
Assassins misery definitely is a stronger effect than Lingering torment, however, it turns it from being a damage over time skill into a filler spammable type skill, in which case i'd much rather just spam frost reach for the weapon and spell damage bonus in addition to not having to sit there hardcasting.I really hope that there are more plans in the future to introduce the frost script to more of the scribing skills as its very disappointing to recieve 2 of these lackluster abilities as the only 2 new scribing skills that even work with frost damage.
I wish the damage options on the primary scripts was this - basically a 'damage' tab that when you select it you can then pick any damage type. This change alone would make you have MANY more frost skills i.e. smash, torch bearer etc.
Primary script
>Damage (which loads separate menu - see below):
..........Frost
..........Poison
..........Fire
..........Defile
..........ETC.
>Healing
>Shield
etc.The contingency name doesn't feel right in its current design. I wish it had more control over the proc in the secondary scripts which let you focus on your playstyle/needs - in this case a magden:
- Script of delaying strike [amplify the effect by 40% but cause the effect to trigger after 3 seconds e.g. 10k spamable becomes 14k burst skill] creating a frost burst skill.
- Script of affliction [Amplify the the damage by 100% but spread the damager over 20s i.e. 10k spamable becomes 20k dot]
- Script of contingency [when below 50% of your primary stat cause the trigger]
- Script of Emergency [when below 30% hp cause the effect] i.e. auto heal
- Script of freedom [when afflicted with a snare or immobilize trigger the effect] e.g. auto snare removal or heal or armour buff as big hit coming
- Script of protection [The next time you take damage, the effect is triggered] e.g. make it give armour buff
- Script of foresight [The next time you damage a target, trigger the effect] i.e. cast skill to give crit buffs or damage buffThoughts?
i understand why its probs not there at launch, because they need additional vfx and sound effects to make it work, but they should retroactively introduce every damage type to every damage grimoire.
PvE Frost Warden Main and teacher for ESO-U. Frost Warden PvE Build Article: https://eso-u.com/articles/nightingales_warden_dps_guide__frost_knight. Come Join the ESO Frost Discord to discuss everything frost!: https://discord.gg/5PT3rQX
#11
4
ESO_Nightingale
✭✭✭✭✭
✭✭✭✭Unified_Gaming wrote: »
NyassaV wrote: »
Ulfsild's Contingency is going to be very good for PvP. It's basically budget Shalks.
It is awkward to use as it doesn't delay well. You cast it then the next resource cost procs it i.e. roll dodge. This means you can't use it on nb say you cast the contingency then cloak - skill proc'd so can't open with it. Cast it then spamable you get a little extra but not enough to make it a burst skill so again feels wasted and better just doing 2 spamables for more net damage as it is an aoe skill so hits less than single target.
i didn't know this casted upon roll dodge, thats really interesting actually.
PvE Frost Warden Main and teacher for ESO-U. Frost Warden PvE Build Article: https://eso-u.com/articles/nightingales_warden_dps_guide__frost_knight. Come Join the ESO Frost Discord to discuss everything frost!: https://discord.gg/5PT3rQX
#12
Unified_Gaming
✭✭✭✭
ESO_Nightingale wrote: »
Unified_Gaming wrote: »
NyassaV wrote: »
Ulfsild's Contingency is going to be very good for PvP. It's basically budget Shalks.
It is awkward to use as it doesn't delay well. You cast it then the next resource cost procs it i.e. roll dodge. This means you can't use it on nb say you cast the contingency then cloak - skill proc'd so can't open with it. Cast it then spamable you get a little extra but not enough to make it a burst skill so again feels wasted and better just doing 2 spamables for more net damage as it is an aoe skill so hits less than single target.
i didn't know this casted upon roll dodge, thats really interesting actually.
Yeah, I am unsure if it also procs on block as you drain resources too. It just made it really clunky to use to be honest. You cast the skill then it is used next action so no contingency at all.
Unified Gaming - creating a shared and Unified Gaming community.
For some of the best and most up to date PVP builds around or useful tips and tricks from an experienced player for PvP and PvE, then check out my channel and consider subscribing if you want to see regular ESO content.
#13
MashmalloMan
✭✭✭✭✭
✭✭✭✭Agreed, this isn't even specifically an issue for Frost skills, it applies to most of the element options.
I fully expected 8 choices per grimoire, especially because of U41 status effect improvements. It was concerning in the chapter preview to see vault with only 4, but it was an obvious work in progress so the hope lived on. It appears the elements picked per grimoire were somewhat based on the theme of the line. Eg. Mages Guild using magic, frost, and flame damage.
I'm okay with 3-4 elements per Grimoire as an introduction IF they provide at least 1 magical AND martial option... but why did they have to default to physical/magic damage so much where they didn't need to?
1h + shield, 2h, and dw all use magic damage instead of throwing in a shock and frost option in there. Obvious opportunity for 4 magical elements, 4 martial weapons, 1 per. On the flip side, Destro and Resto don't have a single martial option.
Below is a list I created of damage focuses to show how poorly varied the elements are. I did not include anything that reduces the damage to offer a different effect like stun, cc, aoe, etc.
Martial = 16
- Physical = 9
- Bleed = 3
- Poison = 2
- Disease = 2
Magical = 18
- Magic = 9
- Flame = 4
- Shock = 3
- Frost = 2
Physical and magic damage are the basic elements, so I understand they are typically more common, but in a case like Scribing I expected much more of an even balance. This feels extremely disproportionate.
Edited by MashmalloMan on April 25, 2024 12:05AM
PC Beta - 1900+ CP
Stam Sorc Khajiit PvE/PVP Main || Stam Sorc Dark Elf PvP ||
Stam Templar Dark Elf || Stam Warden Wood Elf || Stam DK Nord || Stam Necro Orc || Stam Blade KhajiitMag Sorc High Elf || Mag Templar High Elf || Mag Warden Breton || Mag Necro Khajiit || Mag Blade Khajiit
#14
3
Hottytotz
✭✭✭
Super disappointed in the scribing abilities so far. Its like ZoS has no idea what these abilities even should be used for. MANY classes have been asking to have an elemental RANGED damage spammable for 5-6 years now. Not having ONE of these abilities fill that role is a huge fkk up. Warden have wanted a frost spammable that isnt reach, fire dk have wanted a ranged fire spammable
>that ISNT reach, sorcs have wanted a lightning spammable since the LAUNCH of the game. How do you screw this up so badly?
#15
Seraphayel
✭✭✭✭✭
✭✭✭✭✭Hottytotz wrote: »
Super disappointed in the scribing abilities so far. Its like ZoS has no idea what these abilities even should be used for. MANY classes have been asking to have an elemental RANGED damage spammable for 5-6 years now. Not having ONE of these abilities fill that role is a huge fkk up. Warden have wanted a frost spammable that isnt reach, fire dk have wanted a ranged fire spammable
>that ISNT reach, sorcs have wanted a lightning spammable since the LAUNCH of the game. How do you screw this up so badly?
But there‘s a ranged spammable for Soul Magic Scribing that also doubles down as an execute with Oblivion damage on top. Yes, it doesn’t deal frost damage (as of now), but it’s totally valid as a spammable.
PS5
EU
Aldmeri Dominion
- Khajiit Arcanist -
#16
Hottytotz
✭✭✭
Seraphayel wrote: »
Hottytotz wrote: »
Super disappointed in the scribing abilities so far. Its like ZoS has no idea what these abilities even should be used for. MANY classes have been asking to have an elemental RANGED damage spammable for 5-6 years now. Not having ONE of these abilities fill that role is a huge fkk up. Warden have wanted a frost spammable that isnt reach, fire dk have wanted a ranged fire spammable
>that ISNT reach, sorcs have wanted a lightning spammable since the LAUNCH of the game. How do you screw this up so badly?
But there‘s a ranged spammable for Soul Magic Scribing that also doubles down as an execute with Oblivion damage on top. Yes, it doesn’t deal frost damage (as of now), but it’s totally valid as a spammable.
Is that what was asked for??? Can you read and comprehend? Elemental spammable to benefit from class passives... Since the start of the game. Yet somehow a ranged oblivion damage spammable seems like a valid response to you? I thought it was the state of ZoS's ineptitude that was slowly killing the game but maybe its also the ineptitude of its players as well. Obviously all of these classes have a "valid" spammable but thats not what is being asked!
Edited by Hottytotz on April 25, 2024 6:43PM
#17
HomeForums English Public Test Server
Sign In or Register to comment.
